In October 2019, Gerber was photographed getting lunch with Davidson, and soon after, an insider for Us Weekly claimed they were dating after Gerber attended Davidson’s comedy show in November. Things progressed quickly after that, as they were spotted holding hands in NYC and making out in Miami, but in January 2020, the lovebirds decided to take a break so Davidson could focus on his mental health, according to a source for E! News. In February 2020, during a YouTube interview with Charlamagne tha God, Davidson opened up about their romance, saying they were “dating for a few months,” but “it just wasn’t the right place or the right time at all.”