To find a mascara that is flake-free, clump-free, smudge-proof, and affordable is a true challenge. That’s why we love the reassurance of a good customer review. If you’re in the market for a new formula that will thicken, lengthen, or curl your eyelashes, we got you covered with beloved finds from Amazon. We checked out Amazon’s top-rated options that have incredible customer reviews and rounded up the best ones. These mascaras will make your lashes flirty, fluttery, and absolutely gorgeous.

— Additional reporting by Macy Cate Williams